After a non-renewal: the house fixes to do first, ranked

Fix whatever your non-renewal letter names first. After that, start with the fixes you can finish this week and book the slow ones, because the next insurer will ask about all of them. Shop for a new policy while the work goes on rather than after it.

A two-story Spanish style house with a red tile roof and a wood garage door

The short version

  • California requires a non-renewal notice to give "the specific reason or reasons" for it, so start with the fix the letter names.
  • The fastest fixes are clearing the roof and gutters, putting in smoke and carbon monoxide alarms, and strapping the water heater.
  • A new panel, new pipes or a new roof takes weeks and usually a permit, so get a written report before you pay for one.
  • Repairs don't bring the old policy back on their own today, so look for a new policy now and have it start before the old one ends.

Time: a weekend.

How we ranked these fixes

We ranked them by how fast a typical owner can finish each one, fastest first. The time on each item is our estimate for a single-family house rather than a measured figure.

We didn't rank them by how much each fix matters to insurers, because your letter already tells you which one mattered to yours.

Speed comes first because you're on a clock. Under California Insurance Code section 678, your insurer has to mail or deliver the notice at least 75 days before the policy ends. That rises to 90 days for notices under the new rules that start January 1, 2028. A fix that's finished by the time the next insurer looks at the house does more for you than one that's still on your list.

What did your insurer say was wrong?

Read the reason before you buy anything. Section 678 requires the notice to state "the specific reason or reasons for the nonrenewal." If it names the roof or the wiring, that fix goes to the top of your list, wherever it sits in the ranking below.

If the reason is vague, ask for more in writing. Under Insurance Code section 791.10, you can ask for the specific information behind the decision within 90 business days of the notice. The insurer then has 21 business days to answer.

Sometimes the reason is your area rather than your house. A repair won't change that kind of decision. The fixes below still matter, because the next insurer asks about the same roof, wiring and pipes.

The fixes, ranked from fastest to slowest

  1. Clear the roof and gutters, and cut back dead wood.
  2. Put in working smoke and carbon monoxide alarms.
  3. Strap the water heater.
  4. Fix the leaks you can see.
  5. Put a barrier around the pool.
  6. Update an old electrical panel or old wiring.
  7. Replace old supply pipes.
  8. Replace the roof.

1. Clear the roof and gutters, and cut back dead wood

How long: an afternoon to a weekend, unless a tree needs a crew.

If your house is in what California calls the state responsibility area, this one is already the law. Public Resources Code section 4291 requires you to keep the roof "free of leaves, needles, or other vegetative materials." It also requires you to cut any part of a tree within 10 feet of a chimney or stovepipe outlet, and to keep plants over the house "free of dead or dying wood."

Outside that area, it's still the fastest fix on this list. Take dated photos of the roof and gutters when you finish.

2. Put in working smoke and carbon monoxide alarms

How long: an afternoon.

California Health and Safety Code section 13113.7 requires smoke alarms in every home, approved by the State Fire Marshal and installed the way the manufacturer says. Section 17926 adds a carbon monoxide alarm in any home with a gas or other fossil fuel heater or appliance, a fireplace or an attached garage.

Test every alarm after you put it up. Our guide to California's alarm rules goes through where each one goes.

3. Strap the water heater

How long: an afternoon with a strapping kit.

California Health and Safety Code section 19211 requires every residential water heater, old or new, to be "braced, anchored, or strapped" against earthquake motion. The rule covers standard tanks of 120 gallons or less, which are the ones strapping kits are made for. When you sell the house, you have to certify in writing that it's done.

How to strap a water heater for earthquakes has the hardware and the steps. Take a photo of the straps when you're done.

4. Fix the leaks you can see

How long: a day for a dripping supply line, and longer if the leak left damage behind.

A homeowners policy generally doesn't pay for wear and tear, maintenance or neglect. The California Department of Insurance lists them among the perils most policies leave out. So a slow drip under a sink is a repair you pay for either way. The stain it leaves is also something the next inspector can see.

Learn where your main shutoff is before you start. How to find your main water shutoff valve walks you through it. Keep the plumber's invoice and before and after photos.

5. Put a barrier around the pool

How long: a weekend for a safety cover or an alarm, and a few weeks for a fence.

The Insurance Information Institute is an industry group. It says the insurance industry considers a pool an "attractive nuisance" because a pool raises your liability risk. The institute suggests a fence with self-closing gates on all sides, plus alarms and a safety cover.

California sets its own floor when you get a permit to build or remodel a pool at a single-family home. Health and Safety Code section 115922 then requires at least 2 of 7 drowning prevention features. They include a safety cover, a removable mesh fence with a self-closing, self-latching gate, and alarms on the doors to the pool. If you don't have a pool, skip this one.

6. Update an old electrical panel or old wiring

How long: a few weeks, because the work usually needs a permit and a licensed electrician.

California ties wiring to insurance in its own words. Since January 1, 2026, sellers have had to give buyers a notice under Civil Code section 1102.6i. It says "substandard, recalled, or faulty wiring may cause a fire risk and may make it difficult to obtain property insurance."

Start with an electrician's written report on the panel and the wiring. Show it to the insurer or agent and ask what they need changed before you pay for more. If you replace anything, keep the permit, the final inspection and the invoice.

Don't hand this one to a handyman. The Contractors State License Board says an unlicensed person can't take a job that needs a building permit. The same goes for a job worth $1,000 or more in labor and materials. Handyman vs licensed contractor explains which repairs fall on which side.

7. Replace old supply pipes

How long: a few weeks for a repipe, counting bids and the permit.

The Insurance Information Institute says an old plumbing, electrical or heating system makes a home harder to insure, because it raises the chance of fire or water damage. Its advice is to find out "what type of improvements" would make the home more insurable.

Ask the insurer which pipe materials it accepts before you repipe. A plumber's written note on what the pipes are made of, and where any old runs are left, tells an insurer what it needs to know. Keep the permit and the invoice with it.

8. Replace the roof

How long: the longest job on this list, once you count bids, the permit and the roofer's schedule.

Get a roofer's written report first. It should give the roof's age, its material and how many years of life it has left. The report may be all you need.

Beginning January 1, 2028, Insurance Code section 676.14 protects you when a roof inspector you hire and pay for "confirms at least five years of useful roof life remaining." An insurer then can't turn down or non-renew the policy "solely on the basis of the age of the roof." It can still weigh the roof's age along with other reasons.

Before 2028 the report still gives the next insurer facts to work from instead of just the year the house was built. If you do replace the roof, keep the permit, the final inspection, the invoice and the paperwork that shows its fire rating.

Will fixing the house get my old policy back?

Not on its own right now. Until January 1, 2028, section 678 doesn't set up a way to fix the problem and keep the policy. You can still send the insurer your proof and ask in writing whether it changes the decision.

That changes on January 1, 2028, under SB 1301, a 2026 law. When the reason is "a condition that can be remedied by the policyholder," the insurer has to tell you at least 120 days before the policy ends. You then get at least 90 days to make the fix.

You send proof when it's done. The insurer can inspect in person or virtually. It has to answer in writing within 15 days of getting your proof. A fix the insurer verifies qualifies you for renewal.

What to do with the fixes once they're done

  • Keep one folder with the letter and its envelope, every invoice, permit and final inspection, and your dated photos.
  • Put the new facts on your applications, such as the year of the new roof or panel. 7 application details that trip up a quote covers the answers that have to match the records.
  • Tell the next insurer's inspector what you changed and when. 11 things a home insurance inspector flags shows what they'll look at.
  • Look for the new policy while you work, and have it start before the old one ends.

Shopping while the work goes on

The next insurer quotes the house as it is on the day you apply. So send the paperwork for each job that's finished, and give a date for each one that's booked.

Casa quotes California homes that another insurer has non-renewed. Its questionnaire asks why the last policy ended, what year the roof went on and when the wiring and plumbing were last updated. The folder above has those answers. Casa checks standard insurers first, then specialty insurers if needed. If the old policy ends soon, the plan for the weeks after a non-renewal notice from Casa, whose team runs this site, goes through what to do before that date.

Questions people ask

Should I finish the fixes before I shop for a new policy?

No. Shop while you work, because the notice period keeps running either way. Tell each insurer what's done and what's booked. Send the paperwork as each job is finished.

Which fixes need a licensed contractor?

Any job that needs a building permit or is worth $1,000 or more in labor and materials, according to the Contractors State License Board. Panels, repipes and roofs usually fall on that side. Your city or county building department can tell you which jobs need a permit.

What if my insurer says the reason is my area rather than my house?

Then no repair changes that insurer's decision. Do the fixes anyway, starting with the fast ones, because the next insurer will ask about the same roof, wiring, pipes and water heater.

Sources

Keep reading

More from Dropped